Friday, June 27, 2003

Dragging Things Back Down

That post on Hobbes elevated the tone around here up to nosebleed level, and it's for me to drag it back down. I can't much figure out how, though. It is too hot here in decaying Worcester, MA, to think about much of anything at all.

But here's an observation: these New Englanders love their Dunkin Donuts. I have heard the Doc say, often, "Man, I don't know, but that Dunkin Donuts has wicked good coffee." Here it is, hotter than these people are used to, and they are still walking around town with super-sized Dunkin Donuts cups in their hands. And they ain't Dunkinfrappacinno's, let me tell ya! This is hot Java that they're sucking up!

Moral of the observation: The true Yankee knows what they like, and sticks to it, regardless of the circumstance. It's either stubborness, bullheadedness or impressive consistency: you be the judge.
Hobbes Locked Out

After yesterday's Court ruling that sodomy is included among those "rights" protected under the 14th Amendment's provisions for privacy and individual liberty, it occurs to me that that dusty British Whig John Locke is ascendant if not already triumphant. Not that he was ever descendent, but Lockean individual natural rights to life, liberty, and property were at least (until recently) subject to the prudent checks of social stigma and what was, to use a colonial phrase, "meet and convenient." Liberty went only so far as "the soft collar of social esteem" allowed it, marking that happy combination of liberty and order. The two were meant for each other, a match made in human nature/heaven. Most saw that liberty without order was anarchy, and order without liberty was tyranny. Seems sensible, no?

No longer. Increasingly, all infringements on individual rights are seen not only as violations of something natural to man but unconstitutional. Virtually nothing that society at large deems necessary for political, social, or moral order is allowable, legal, or defensible -- to defend such things marks one for several varieties of hatred and isms. And so, we have this interesting combination (some might say contradiction) of an increasingly democratic world with fewer and fewer matters open to majority rule. If we embrace democracy and majority rule, yet tell majorities they have no right telling other people how to live, what will be left to decide? Won't democracy be merely a shell, a quasi-libertarian system where everybody does as they please, society and majorities be damned?

Which brings to mind the much abused "Monster of Malmesbury" Thomas Hobbes, a thinker shoved into the shadows by the Lockeans. Hobbes saw that liberty without order, which truly is man in a state of nature, was a nightmare. Everyone following their own little versions of happiness (or in Hobbes' eloquent word "felicity"), everyone an atom unconcerned with others unless others infringed on my pursuit of happiness. Such a life is ultimately unliveable and, using Hobbes' famous phrase, "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."

Hasn't this come to pass? A Lockean world of individual rights is one profoundly solitary. The quality of modern life is often poor, nasty, course, and unsatisfying. Blind pursuits of happiness contra society do indeed have a brutish quality, natural man satisfying his wants against the competition and criticism of others, leading too many to rather short unhappy lives.

So while Locke may smile that the world is his, Hobbes may frown that it is his too. Only no one realized that Hobbes' "war of all against all" was not heaven, but a hell of our own making.

Thursday, June 26, 2003

The History of Anti-Americanism

Anti-Americanism has a history. That is something I am apt to forget. I often mistakenly believe that America has always been seen as a beacon for the blah-blah-blah. Nothing could be further from the truth. Much of the European interaction with America has been with a shadow America, or rather a white screen on which Europeans project their own emotions and, often enough, insecurities. For examples, see Charles Dicken's account of his travels in America, and Frances Trollope's pitiless take upon the United States. And they just found Americans had poor manners. Others are apt to find all sorts of things they don't like in Europe here in America, writ large.

Someone who knows a lot more about this than I is James W. Ceasar, Professor of Political Thought at the University of Virginia. His brilliant article "A genealogy of anti-Americanism" is online at The Public Interest website. It is a must read, and I plan to make some more comments on it tomorrow.
Speaking of Hot

Having apparently few other topics of interest to which to devote their collected brainpower, the Royal Society of Chemists and the Institute of Physics in the UK are wrangling over how to produce the best cup of tea. The physicists claim that the chemists are over complicating the matter, and the chemists sneer that the physicists’ obsession with simplification applies on so many levels.

I would like to put in a plea for scientific unity and argue that, if you follow both sets of advice, you will come up with a truly superlative brew. But it did not take the chemists and the physicists to tell me this. The most useful and enchanting book ever written about tea, Malachi McCormick’s A Decent Cup of Tea, clued me in to this long ago.

I must also give a cry of triumph over the RSC’s curt dismissal of the tea bag. When last in England I became involved in a tea disputation, and sides ended up oddly divided with Americans backing loose leaf tea and the Brits backing tea bags. Is this the pernicious effect of “Cool Britannia”? If it meant that one could get a decent cup of coffee throughout England, I suppose that would be progress of a sort, but those that have lived there have stories about the coffee that make my hair do the fretful porpentine. Besides with tea bags, you get all that extra paper littering the harbor, and those little strings would wrap around the necks of indigenous waterfowl. Loose leaf is much more versatile.
Indeed it is hot here in New England, all the more oppressive because we completely skipped over spring. It rained and rained and rained March to June, and then rather suddenly popped up to 90 degrees around June 23. But after a winter of extraordinary snowiness, I will take it.

By the way, I am back after yet another hiatus and appreciate my comrades for their "picking up the slack."

I think this is a fabulously brave and "spot on" article by John Derbyshire on homosexuality in the Anglican and Roman Catholic Churches. I worked four years in an American seminary, watching and digesting many disturbing things, and Derbyshire's comments hit home. Oh the things I saw; oh the things I could relate! But since that particular religious society was darn good to me, and I am as loyal as a dog, any exposes will have to wait. Suffice to say, JD is on to something here.

A book review by Roger Scruton, lamenting excessive democratism and pleading for the necessity of (and the inevitability of) elites. We like Scruton.

I may put this book on my summer list, an academic thriller based upon the disputed authorship of William Shakespeare. And the prevailing current in DC today may be Wilsonian (a tide I often happily ride upon), but being positive about Woodrow Wilson is still hard for me. He gave us the income tax and he maligned a foreign policy based on national interest. I'd have voted for Taft.

And check out the latest Books & Culture website for several interesting articles on the Civil War, thinking ahead to next week's 140th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg. Hmmm, this being true I do believe I will begin posting some Civil War thoughts seeing as this is one of my specialities and research interests (especially the causes thereof 1820-1860).


Lack of a Temperate Climate

It is, btw, dang hot here in central New England. Especially for someone who has spent three years in England, where they have a temperate climate, with a narrow range of possibilities, usually a binary option of light drizzle or brilliant sunshine. On Sunday it was cold enough that you had to wear a fleece everywhere. Today it's shorts, t-shirt and sandals. Such craziness! Americans just don't appreciate that even in the most mild and temperate of their regions the weather seems extreme.
Here in the Heart of New England

I have been in Worcester, Massachusetts for the last week or so. It's a pretty sad city. At some point everybody decided to move into the near suburbs, leaving the heart of Worcester desolate and lonely. But there are some real gems in this town. One of them is the American Antiquarian Society.

The AAS is a great big collection of old books. It has "American" in its title. But it is really a repository of New England greatness. This is true even of the portraits that they have in their main reading room. I sit at a table under the dome of the AAS, reading about Virginian controversies of the 18th century...but all the while John Winthrop, founder of the Massachusetts Bay Colony is staring sternly down at me. Cotton Mather, just to his right, looks a lot more benign. You can see why he and Ben Franklin got along. And in a seated pose and with what can only be described as a heroic frame, Calvin Coolidge is bigger than any of them; he doesn't look at you, just stares off stage with a content expression on his face, as if he's just seen Hoover lose his re-election attempt.

Sunday, June 22, 2003

Weekend Roundup

Let's just think of this as Close-of-the-Century Heroes Weekend. That would be the 18th century, not the 20th. At a time when major networks are vying to get a wounded Army private into a music video if she would just talk to them first, it's nice to think about what John Paul Jones would have done to an MTV producer if they had gotten in his way as he came out of a bar.

But, in all honesty, if it had guaranteed him enough publicity to give him a chance at a ship, I think Jones would have been on MTV in a flash. Evan Thomas, a Newsweek reporter and amateur sailor has written a new biography of Chevalier Jones. Here's the NY Times review. But as good as the book sounds, as compelling as its subject is, to be honest it seems hard to write a lot about John Paul Jones. Sure, there are some thriling sea battles to chronicle. There is a larger than life character to depict, who actually thought hard about how to beat his opponent. But Jones is a very minor character in the American Revolution. If you think of the Revolution as a grand narrative, it's hard to find a place to shove him in. His greatest victory, at Flamborough Head, is a sort of naval side-show, remarkable because it was the one frigate single-ship action of the Revolution that the US Navy won. Yes, yes, Jefferson and Washington both had his bust in their homes; but surely that was because Houdon had done it, just as he had done their busts. The book to read would be one that covered the privateers who did serious damage to British trade, and who fought the occasional rousing battle. But it hasn't been written yet, not to the required standard of dual narrative and analysis.

Also in the Time, in one of those excellent editorial decisions, is a review of the new biography of Horatio Nelson, entitled Nelson: Love and Fame. It's by Edgar Vincent, and it sounds like a great read, having both sound writing and some penetrating analysis. Sure, it is more than a little bit annoying to be told that "Nelson invented the modern system of mission command, based on consultation and coordination rather than hierarchical obedience, pioneering methods of management that are standard practice on Wall Street today"...as if Nelson was the first commander to call a council of war. But Vincent (a former naval officer and--gasp!--management consultant) at least has an eye for such things, an eye which academics and professional biographers intent on finding the real Nelson are too busy to develop.

But even Horation Nelson, as influential as he is, can't compete with John Wesley's influence. Nelson defeated a fleet; Wesley inspired a movement that converted nations. This is, roughly, the three hundredth anniversary of Wesley's birth. An article in Christianity Today Online entitled "How John Wesley Changed America" is a good place to start reading.



The Life It Saves May Be Your Own...

This just in from ScrappleFace, the indispensable news source:

(2003-06-21) -- A 14-year-old Philadelphia boy was treated and released from a hospital this morning after being shot in the chest by a friend who wanted his new copy of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix , according to a news release from Bloomsbury, the publisher of the book.

Physicians say the boy would be dead but the bullet struck the 870-page book first, leaving the child with only minor injuries.

Harry Potter turns out to also be involved with events in Israel:

-- Hamas, the Palestinian terrorist group, agreed to a 72-hour cease fire with Israel to allow its young homicide bombers time to read the new J.K. Rowling offering.

Hey, who are you going to get your news from? Some shady outfit like The New York Times?

Wednesday, June 18, 2003

Swede Watch

The French? Pah! They are of no concern! The people I keep an eye on are the Swedes.

Don't believe me? Look at the wackiness they can make people do. Or, to be fair, the things people do for them. Pavlov's dogs had it easy.

I mean, doesn't it make you wonder, how they manufactured and sold the two ugliest car lines in the history of the automotive industry?
Jersey Lightning

The ever excellent Washington Post Food section has an article about an indomitable duo's quest to drink a Jack Rose in a DC bar. It's excellent reading except for one crucial error. Their relation of the history of applejack is foul beyond compare, giving credit for this fine beverage to "New England" with no mention of the real perpetuating source of applejack: New Jersey. Sure other places had some form of applejack, but the real source, and the one that kept it on the beverage shelf, was little N.J., thanks to a Scots immigrant from Fife who set up a distillery in the then Colony of New Jersey. Laird's distillery in Colt's Neck, NJ was a main supplier of the spirit since the early 1700's and remains so to this day. (The distillery though is no longer in NJ, but now is located in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia, a change that your correspondent finds pleasing in its relation to her own meanderings. I just followed the applejack.). Yo Jack Rose lads, your quest for the cocktail is admirable, but if you’re going to praise the applejack, give credit where it’s properly due. Or at least brush up on your geography.
A Relief

Human cases of West Nile haven't hit Canada...yet.

Tuesday, June 17, 2003

Lawn Ornaments III

Saw a new one last week. I am used to the black outline of the cowboy, no matter that it looks slightly out of place on the east coast. But it took me a while to realize that what I was looking at was a cowgirl. How PC.

Why doesn't someone come up with some regional outlines? In Maine they should have codgers with beards and oilskin caps and souwesters on their lawns...they should outline well. In Pennsylvania they could have Amish chaps with beards and flat hats. Regional authenticity for lawn ornaments!

The ultra-expensive Frontgate catalog, btw, is selling Murano glass balls for your front yard. Yes, you can wipe the eyes of your neighbors by putting this exquisite handblown ornament in your front yard. Positioned, no doubt, atop a pedestal of Carerra marble.
This Day in History: The Battle of Bunker Hill

It should of course, as countless pedants like to point out, be called the "Battle of Breed's Hill". Bunker Hill had an earthwork on top of it, but no business resulted. The action occurred a half mile to the east, on the slopes of Breed's Hill.

All in all it was a lousy idea to occupy that hill. The Americans were, no doubt, thinking that with such a commanding position they could rain down artillery fire upon the British fleet in Boston harbor. But what artillery did they plan to use? They had none; and the Rebel army outside Boston would be without cannon sufficient to threaten the Royal Navy until the next winter, after Henry Knox's epic march from Ticonderoga on Lake Champlain.

What they were, those New Englanders on the Charleston peninsula, was bait. And the British Army rose at the offer. They embarked in their longboats, headed out into the Charles River, and prepared to hit the Rebel positions from three sides. It would end the Massachusetts rebellion in one decisive stroke.

In the end it did not work like that. Time and tide and the complexity of the landscape funneled the British assault into a frontal attack. And it was not just Massachusetts that the British marched against. On that day they confronted all of New England. There were Massachusetts men in the redoubt on Breed's Hill, sure enough, while William Prescott paced back and forth on the ramparts for all to see. But those were men of Connecticut behind the rail fence who awaited the assault of the Guards. Rhode Island men waited in trenches. And that was John ("Live Free or Die") Stark of New Hampshire on the beach behind the stone wall that he had had built in haste, waiting for the light infantry to come in lines of eight abreast.

In the end, of course, the Rebels lost. They were driven from that hill in a rout. But that rout presaged the majority of battles for the next eight years. Time after time the British Army, in good 18th century fashion, would hold the ground when the battle was over. But they did it at considerable cost. Veterans of wars with the French would say, after Bunker Hill, that they had never known such ferocious combat. They said it with pride, then, because they believed that they were fighting fellow Englishmen who would always fight better than the Frogs ever could. Yet they would continue to say the same thing in the long years ahead when even the most ardent proponent of British imperial rule admitted that they were no longer fighting Britons, but Americans.

There's a great website on the Battle of Bunker Hill courtesy of the Massachusetts Historical Society. Check it out.
See What Socialized Medicine Gets You

Toronto, Disease Capital of North America.

I have to add that I hope that if this man has West Nile, he acquired it when traveling to somewhere warm. Otherwise there is a truly scary vector up there in Canada. The US only acquired its first potential case this week, and it was in balmy South Carolina, which makes far more sense than Canada, where as the article notes, cases weren't expected to appear until August.



Blah, blah, blah. History, history, history. Now that I have rediscovered my pass code, it is time this blog was livened up, which means a return to the last interesting topic raised: lawn ornaments.

Ever since Dr. C's FASCINATING diatribe thereupon, I have been giving close scrutiny to the lawn decoration ethos of various areas. First, as I was abroad when Dr. C's genius struck, I observed lawn decoration in the environs of Oxford, England. It uniformly consisted of burgeoning roses that apparently grow like weeds, tasteful, but uninspired. Though the garden display at the local ironmongers promised great things, gnary a gnome did I see. Thus the most interesting lawn ornament display abroad award goes to St. John's College, Oxford, which had a teddy bear hanging by the neck in its garden.

The inner suburbs of Washington, DC also are unfertile territory. The best we have is the occasional reflecting ball, the odd flamingo, and geese in matching outfits, but the geese tend to coyly peer out from porches, as if afraid to brave the greater world of the yard while wearing a ballerina's tutu, and who can blame them?

Southern New Jersey has more in the area of lawn ornaments, but they generally are limited in scope. They consist of the silhouettes popular a decade ago that linger on (The slouching cowboy; the dog and cat), the ever popular lawn deer (an ornament I find very puzzling in an area overrun by the real thing, unless of course clever hunters use them as decoys), geese whirligigs (ditto), the odd reflecting ball, and, for the Catholic, and invariably Italian, population, a statue of the Virgin. To be sure, there is a man on Almond Road whose yard is well...like Disneyland in miniature, but he is the exception rather than the rule.

No, from what I've observed in my travels, the Mecca for lawn ornaments is New England, even more than in the South where your neighbors are apt to use your lawn ornaments for a bit of traget practice. (Although to be sure, there are things like mini-Graceland, but that's not really a lawn ornament.) Yes indeed, Ex Nova Anglia Semper Aliquid Novi. If New England doesn't have it as a lawn ornament, it doesn't exist. From the enthusiasm with which New England yards embrace the lawn ornament, it makes you wonder if they weren't mentioned in the Mayflower Compact.

"In the name of God, Amen. We, whose names are underwritten, the loyal subjects of our dread Sovereigne Lord, King James, by the grace of God, of Great Britaine, France and Ireland king, defender of the faith, etc. having undertaken, for the glory of God, and advancement of the Christian faith, and honour of our king and country, a voyage to plant the first colony in the Northerne parts of Virginia, doe by these presents solemnly and mutually in the presence of God and one of another, covenant and combine ourselves together into a civill body politick, for our better ordering and preservation, and furtherance of the ends aforesaid; by virtue hereof to enacte, constitute, and frame such just and equall laws, ordinances, acts, lawne decorations, constitutions and offices, from time to time, as shall be thought most meete and convenient for the generall good of the Colonie unto which we promise all due submission and obedience.."

Oh dear, I mentioned history and Virginia and New England. None of us are safe....
Crime Prevention and Other Things

Now this is the way to treat criminals! Guy gets robbed and the bad guys flee in car. So what does the guy do? He chases them in his Hummer and eventually runs over the getaway car. That's right, the Hummer (like a tank) rolls over the getaway car.

Big day in Republican history: 147 years ago today, the Republican Party opened its first national convention in Philadelphia, eventually leading to the nomination of the "Pathfinder" John C. Fremont. Polled pretty well in a three man race versus Buchanan and Fillmore. Later had a disasterous (he had no political nose at all, which makes one wonder how he would have fared as president) Civil War career. And 31 years ago today, 5 men were caught burglarizing the DNC at DC's Watergate complex, which nixed Nixon two years later. So in one day, you have the highs and lows of one political party.

Today is also the anniversary of the Battle of Bunker Hill, but I will leave that to my colonialist comrade.

Monday, June 16, 2003

Interesting only to me, perhaps

Isn't it interesting that in the election of 1860, Vice-President John C. Breckinridge polled more votes in Massachusetts (6,163, 3.6%) and Maine (6,368, 6.3%), than Illinois (2,331, 0.7%), Iowa (1,035, 0.8%), Michigan (805, 0.5%), Minnesota (748, 2.1%), and Wisconsin (887, 0.6%) combined? He polled no votes at all in Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey (probably because the ballots did not include his name), but got 218 in Vermont, 2,125 in New Hampshire, and whopping 14,372 (19.2%, just barely beaten by Douglas) in Connecticut. In fact, Breck polled a higher percentage of votes in CT than either Indiana or Missouri. So, which is really the abolitionist homeland, New England or the Old Northwest?

Just thought you'd like to know. Maybe.
"He cannot control his Natural Passion," indeed. Jackson probably had the nerve to grab the salt shaker without asking Jefferson first. "The barbarian! The knave!" To be a fly on the wall for that dinner!

I too want to read that Burstein book, although being a Jacksonian partisan I am suspicious already.
"He cannot control his Natural Passion"

Having discussed Polk, who can resist mentioning Old Hickory, Andrew Jackson himself, Polk's political mentor? Polk was called "Young Hickory" by both admirers and despisers. Both of them were "Scots-Irish", Protestants from Northern Ireland whose families came orginally from the British borderlands; and both of them were North Carolinians who emigrated to Tennessee.

One of the best popular historians around is John Buchanan. That's what I think having read his The Road to Guilford Courthouse, which chronicles the southern campaign of the American Revolution. Buchanan now has a book out entitled Jackson's Way: Andrew Jackson and the People of the Western Waters . I haven't read it, but from what I can gather, it doesn't seem the most PC of books. Buchanan seems to be of the opinion that all them thar Indians needed some killin', and by gar! That thar Jackson, he war the one t'do it! He also contends that the settling of what we now think of the "Deep South" but was then the "Southwest" was the real drama of western expansion; everything else was relatively easy...and I am bound to say that I agree with that premise.

For a very different take on Old Hickory, I am looking forward to getting a hold of Andrew Burstein's The Passions of Andrew Jackson. Burstein wrote to what is my mind the most perceptive and fundamentally decent book on Thomas Jefferson, The Inner Jefferson: Portrait of a Grieving Optimist. It is a book without any hagiography of the old Dumas Malone "Mr. Jefferson" School or any of the pious umbrage that recent scholars seem to enjoy wallowing in whenever they discuss Jefferson. And it is beautifully written, as well. The Passions of Andrew Jackson should be a good summer read.

"He cannot control his Natural Passion" was, by the way, Jefferson's assessment of Jackson after Old Hickory had dinner at Monticello. It is hard to imagine, for Jefferson, a more fundamental and serious criticism. Read Burstein to find out why.